When most people think about building materials, they default to new lumber from a home improvement store or lumber yard. Reclaimed lumber is a different kind of material, with its own strengths and its own trade-offs. Here is how the two compare.
Density and Grain
Much reclaimed lumber comes from old-growth trees that grew slowly in dense, natural forests. That slow growth produces wood with tighter growth rings and often higher density than fast-grown modern timber of the same species. Reclaimed heart pine is a well-known example: it is typically denser and harder than modern plantation-grown southern yellow pine.
Denser, tighter-grained wood tends to resist denting and wear well, which is why reclaimed material is popular for flooring and for beams. Every piece is different, though, so grade and condition still need to be checked board by board.
Dimensional Stability
New framing lumber is commonly dried to 19 percent moisture content or less, and interior finish lumber is usually dried to a lower range, often around 6 to 8 percent. Reclaimed lumber has often been seasoned in place for decades, and has been through many seasonal cycles of humidity change. Once it has acclimated to its new environment, it is frequently quite stable.
Any wood still moves with changes in humidity, so reclaimed lumber should be acclimated before installation and stored flat and dry. See our Moisture Guide for the basics.
Character and Appearance
No factory finish can fully replicate the patina of wood that has aged for a century. The color variation, weathered texture, nail holes, and saw marks are the marks of the structure the wood came from. Designers and architects often choose reclaimed wood for exactly this reason, whether the project is a barn wood accent wall or a refined walnut dining table.
Environmental Considerations
Reusing lumber has a few straightforward benefits, with some caveats:
- Reusing lumber avoids cutting new timber for that use
- It keeps usable wood out of the waste stream
- It skips the logging and primary milling steps that new lumber requires
- Salvaging, de-nailing, trucking, and re-milling still take energy, so the benefit depends on the material and how far it travels
Large Sizes
Old-growth trees produced large, clear timbers that are hard to find new today. Large-section beams and wide boards turn up in old barn, mill, and warehouse buildings, and reclaimed lumber is often the practical source for big timbers used in timber framing and exposed beam work. What is available at any given time depends on partner suppliers.
The Trade-Offs
Reclaimed lumber is not the right answer for every job. It can contain nail holes and hidden metal, vary in color and dimension, and take more care to source and prepare than new stock. Availability and pricing vary by supplier. If you are weighing reclaimed against new, request a quote and a partner supplier in our network will follow up with what is available for your project.